Shelter Island Heights, NY | CrimeLocal Your Source for Local Crime News

Shooting

3/15/26

Federal street and huntington street, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Shooting

3/15/26

Rosemary street and crystal avenue, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Theft

3/7/26

1700 block of old country road, riverhead

A Woman Stole Assorted Clothing And Household Items, Valued At $538, From Store.

Theft

3/1/26

1600 block of old country road, riverhead

A Man Stole Assorted Meat Products Valued At Approximately $380 From Store.

Shooting

2/15/26

00 block of connecticut avenue, new london

SHOOTING VICTIM - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Theft

2/14/26

1700 block of west main st, riverhead

A Woman Stole Assorted Clothing, Valued At Approximately $515 From Store.

Shooting

1/26/26

Williams street and garfield avenue, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Shooting

1/18/26

Coit street and w connecticut avenue, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Shooting

1/5/26

12000 block of branford rd, branford

A Person Was Reported Shot, And Ems Was Called To The Scene.

Shooting

12/22/25

100 block of garfield avenue, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Theft

12/20/25

1700 block of old country road, riverhead

A Man And Woman Stole Assorted Merchandise.

Theft

12/11/25

1700 block of old country road, riverhead

A Woman Who Was Possibly Working With Two Other People Stole Assorted Merchandise From A Store, The Merchandise Was Valued At Approximately $560.

Theft

11/28/25

Main street, southampton

A Report Of A Possible Theft.

Shooting

11/22/25

00 block of farnsworth street, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Shooting

11/15/25

00 block of eastern avenue, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Shooting

11/13/25

Franklin street and home street, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Other

10/23/25

600 block of riverside dr, riverhead

A Report Of Domestic Dist.

Theft

10/19/25

1700 block of w main st, riverhead

A Man Stole Multiple Pairs Of Shoes, Valued At A Combined $772.

Theft

10/15/25

1700 block of west main street, riverhead

A Man Stole Approximately $350 Worth Of Merchandise.

Theft

10/13/25

1400 block of old country road, riverhead

A Woman Stole Legos.

Theft

10/13/25

500 block of saw mill road, west haven

A Report Of A Shoplifting-In-Progress.

Theft

10/6/25

1500 block of old country road, riverhead

A Man Stole Merchandise, Valued At $400.

Theft

9/25/25

00 block of country road 39, southampton

A Man And Woman Stole Merchandise.

Theft

9/21/25

1600 block of old country road, riverhead

A Woman Stole Alcohol From Stop.

Robbery

9/18/25

400 block of ocean ave, new london

A Report Of A Robbery, The Suspect Fled The Location With A Sum Of Money Before Officers Arrived At The Scene.

Theft

9/17/25

1700 block of old country road, riverhead

A Man Stole Approximately $575 Worth Of Merchandise.

Theft

9/2/25

1400 block of old country road, riverhead

A Man Stole An Assortment Of Cleaning Supplies The Merchandise Was Valued At Approximately $450.

Theft

8/26/25

1700 block of w main st, riverhead

A Man Stole Nearly $200 Worth Of Clothing.

Shooting

8/15/25

00 block of grove street, new london

CRO SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Other

8/14/25

00 block of emerson pl, sag harbor

A Report Of A Domestic Dist.

Theft

8/7/25

1700 block of w main st, riverhead

Two Women Stole Shoes, Valued At Nearly $500.

Shooting

8/3/25

00 block of hawthorne drive, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Theft

8/3/25

1800 block of old country road, riverhead

A Man Stole An Xbox Controller From Walmart.

Shooting

8/2/25

Bank street and tilley street, new london

SHOTS FIRED INCIDENT - THIS IS FROM THE NEW LONDON POLICE CALL LOG. INFORMATION IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE.

Theft

8/1/25

1700 block of w main st, riverhead

A Man Stole Approximately $415 Worth Of Clothing.

Shooting

2/15/26

Connecticut ave and prest st, new london

Shooting/Stabbing. U/D: PD rptg the victim is deceased at the hospital

Shooting

2/15/26

Connecticut ave and prest st, new london

Shooting/Stabbing. NLPD o/s adult male shot in the leg

Robbery

2/4/26

100 block of rt 32, montville

Armed Robbery. PD o/s armed robbery at gunpoint of Labella Wine And Liquor, perp is an Older Male

Shooting

12/1/25

Meridian st and rainville ave, groton

Shooting/Stabbing. GPD o/s male shot, manhunt for suspect in area, K-9 tracking

Robbery

11/19/25

400 block of montauk ave, new london

Armed Robbery. Robbery of Liquor Store. Knife Shown. Units o/s Perp Detained. ID made. Checking Video.

Crime News Results near Shelter Island Heights, NY

Shooting

3/15/26

Shooting

3/15/26

Theft

3/7/26

Theft

3/1/26

Shooting

2/15/26

Theft

2/14/26

Shooting

1/26/26

Shooting

1/18/26

Shooting

1/5/26

Shooting

12/22/25

Theft

12/20/25

Theft

12/11/25

Theft

11/28/25

Shooting

11/22/25

Shooting

11/15/25

Shooting

11/13/25

Other

10/23/25

Theft

10/19/25

Theft

10/15/25

Theft

10/13/25

Theft

10/13/25

Theft

10/6/25

Theft

9/25/25

Theft

9/21/25

Robbery

9/18/25

Theft

9/17/25

Theft

9/2/25

Theft

8/26/25

Shooting

8/15/25

Other

8/14/25

Theft

8/7/25

Shooting

8/3/25

Theft

8/3/25

Shooting

8/2/25

Theft

8/1/25

Shooting

2/15/26

Shooting

2/15/26

Robbery

2/4/26

Shooting

12/1/25

Robbery